To buy any of the fine products you see on this webpage, please click the Buy Now Buttons under the products or go directly to our secure Shopping Cart By Following this link.


The Custom Shop and First Command Police Supply:

We have been serving the Town of Walworth and surrounding areas for over two decades. We take pride in delivering the finest Gunsmithing Services in New York State. We also produce our own unique line of firearm cleaning supplies and operate a sizable retail store with an extensive inventory of popular long guns and handguns. We also offer a free Lifetime Warranty on all the Firearms we sell through our brick and mortar store,* as well as a discount on ammunition and select accessories for 6 months and 1 month respectively. With our already low prices, we are offering you the best deal bar none.



The Owner:

David Dentico, is a Master Gunsmith with 32 years of experience, he graduated From the Pennsylvania Gunsmith School in 1984 (PGS). He has served the community as a Volunteer Firefighter, Past President of the Chamber of Commerce as well as through Ducks Unlimited for 30 years, and his retail store and gunsmithing service.



Sales Manager:

David Dodd has an extensive customer service and sales background. He is a competitive shooter in the pistol league at Canandaigua Sportsman's club, an NRA Certified Instructor, and is broadly knowledgeable in many firearm related fields.


Together we promise to deliver the best retail experience and finest supplies available.


Hours of Operation:

Tuesday through Friday 10:00am to 6:00pm, and Saturday 10:00am to 3:00 pm.



3712 Main Street (Walworth Palmyra Rd) in Walworth New York. Our store is located on the South East Corner of 441 (Walworth-Marion Rd, Walworth Penfield Rd) and Walworth Palmyra Road (Main St), between Walworth Hardware and The Cleary Insurance Agency.


Contact Us

Please write to The Custom Shop, Box 410 Walworth, New York 14568, or call us at (315) 986 1717. Our Email address is This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..


*Warranty applies to all firearms sold in the brick and mortar store for more than $ 150.00 and excludes consigned merchandise, and internet orders.

A note to users who have Internet Explorer 10 or older browsers: Internet security protocols have changed, and this site will be updated in late June of 2015. If you use Internet Explorer 10 or older Browsers, your browser will not be configured to handle these new protocols. You may see error messages when attempting to access secure content. Please follow these simple instructions to correctly configure you we browser. How To Use Internet Explorer 10 With Updated Security Protocols